I own a 32 Chevy 2dr totally stock. When I purchased it last year the body etc was pristine. About two months ago I had a dumbass attack and backed my right rear fender into a pick-up tailgate that had been left in the down position. The result was a fender with several creases running in several directions along with a badly mangled lip on the fender.
I was able to find an old time body man who could do repairs without bondo etc. He looked it over and assured me that he could repair the existing fender. Price? Somewhere between $1K to $ 1.5K. He also said it would make a lot more sense to buy a new, repeat NEW fender.
So I did. Bought the fender from the Filling Station
https://www.fillingstation.com/shop/?year=1932&vehtype=Car&search=radio&searchtype=FT . I have an appointment at the end of the month to finish, paint and install the fender for approx. $500. Total projected end cost including freight ($52) to be $1047.
I strongly recommend going this route if your metal has any bad creases or torn metal.